Logan Paul, Nina Agdal Find Out They Are Expecting a Baby Girl

Logan Paul and Nina Agdal have a baby girl on the way.

The YouTuber, 29, and the Danish model, 32, held a wild, wrestling-themed sex reveal to announce to their friends, family and followers that they are expecting a girl.

One of the party’s attendees shared a video on Instagram Stories of the faux wrestling match. Two fighters — one dressed in a blue outfit and the other in a pink outfit — fought, with the winner signifying which sex baby Paul would be. The fight was also jokingly overseen by “referee” Oliver Tree, a fellow YouTuber and comedian.

Teasing the small outdoor crowd, the two fighters got hits in to make viewers think the wrestler signifying a baby boy would win, but in the end, the fighter representing team girl came out on top.

At the end of the match, a cloud of pink smoke was released into the air, while Paul and Agdal could be seen hugging Paul’s brother, Jake Paul, and the rest of their family.

Logan also shared an Instagram post featuring some photos from the fighting-inspired sex reveal, capturing the couple and their family reacting to the news, as well as showing off a novelty bottle of Prime — the Impaulsive podcaster’s energy drink brand — that featured a pink and blue label reading: “Lil Hydration” and “Arriving 2024.”

Wrestling has been a tradition for the Paul family over the last several years. Both Logan and Jake have taken turns trying out both amateur and professional fighting, including in the WWE and in exhibition matches against boxing champion Floyd Mayweather and fellow YouTuber KSI.

Logan and Agdal announced that they are expecting their first baby together on April 15, sharing a photo on Instagram of the pair posing in front of a flowering tree.

“Another Paul coming this Fall 👶🏼 @ninaagdal,” Logan wrote in his caption.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Logan proposed to Agdal in July 2023 and later uploaded a video on his YouTube channel that gave viewers an intimate look at the moment he popped the question while they were on vacation in Lake Como, Italy.

“Today is the day I ask the love of my life to marry me,” he said in the video. “Fourteen months ago, I fell in love with the most beautiful human being I’ve ever seen in my life, and I have been waiting for this day ever since.”